Where? At the workplace! Is the use of vulgarities and obscenities a reality of the modern workplace? Who knows? While many may find the use of profanity and rude behavior offensive, there are no employment laws that require people to be respectful and polite to each other. Contrary to popular belief, anti-discrimination laws do not consider the mere use of vulgar language to constitute a “hostile work environment”.
Clearly, the use of ‘vulgar’ or ‘inappropriate language’is becoming more frequent in all aspects of society, including the workplace. In fact, in some companies simple expletives are viewed as part of the workplace culture and associated with ‘passion for the work’. Scientific American cites a variety of researchers that link the use of swear words to stress relief. Opponents, however, believe that vulgarity dilutes workplace morale, intimidates employees, and causes managers to view an employee who uses expletives as unfit for promotion because of his perceived inability to control his temper.
While one could argue either side of this issue, one fact is clear: Human Resources personnel are walking a fine line between protecting the First Amendment rights of workers while maintaining a safe and professional work environment. A review of recent litigation sheds some light on the courts’ view of this issue.
It took the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) nine years to decide that the yelling of obscenities at a manager in a scuffle by Joe Agins Jr., a barista at Starbucks did NOT merit him losing his job. The argument was triggered when Mr. Agins was participating in an activity to unionize workers. The decision was based not on whether Mr. Agins used profanity, but whether Starbucks violated the worker’s right to pursue a collective bargaining agreement.
Still pending in courts is the case of Nick Aguirre who was overwrought with his working conditions. Two months into a sales job with an auto company, he lost his cool and resorted to profanities and threats when dissatisfied with the responses he was receiving to questions regarding working conditions. He actually told the owner that he was stupid, that nobody liked him and that everyone talked about him behind his back. Mr. Aguirre was fired. Early indications are that the NLRB will side with Mr. Aguirre, viewing the situation as engaging in protected concerted activity – which could include a discussion or complaint about wages, hours, or working conditions.
Finally, there is the case of Griffin vs. City of Portland. Ms. Griffin filed a religious harassment suit. After numerous complaints regarding co-workers who repeatedly took the Lord’s name in vain, a supervisor chastised Ms. Griffin for being a religious fanatic. In this case, the court differentiated between simple expletives that do not indicate religious ideas and profanity that is expressly directed at one’s religious views. In other words, the courts did not take issue with the workers who casually used religious references, but did determine that the supervisor’s comments – directed specifically at Ms. Griffin – constituted a hostile work environment.
Employers have a responsibility to maintain a workplace which is safe and has civilized interaction between all members of its workforce. But, the use of profanity does not automatically qualify as a legal issue. In considering lawsuits, the NLRB and other government agencies use the four-part test devised by the NLRB:
Employers can and should take action to create a culture and work environment that enables everyone to maximize their contribution to the company. DCR advises the following:
Crafting a “language policy” can be complex – the policy must reflect the culture and work environment. Each company differs in where the line should be drawn between tolerance of simple expletives and excessive offensive language. Let us know if your company struggles with this issue. We’d be interested in learning more about ways in which you have addressed the issue.
We are a volunteer group running a Breakfast Club for the homeless and disadvantaged. To deal with the ever-increasing use of profanity and language deemed offensive by some, over a wide age and culture range of people, we crafted the following notice and pinned it to the wall. The use of bad language has dramatically reduced and people seem to be more aware of the sensitivities of others around them as a result. No smacked wrists, no rules to follow, just courtesy and awareness!
‘Please help us to maintain a welcoming, relaxed, atmosphere for everyone attending Breakfast Club by being aware that not everyone is comfortable around profanity. Thanks :-)’
Mail (will not be published) (required)
× three = 24
Thanks for Subscribing to DCR Blog.